where is amityville island

Where is Amityville Island? Location, Map & Travel Guide

By
AD

The question "where is Amityville Island" immediately conjures images of a specific, haunted location, but the reality is far more geographically complex. While the name evokes a singular, ominous island, the truth involves a historical town, a barrier island, and a census-designated place all bound by a shared legend. To understand the location, one must look at the specific coordinates on Long Island, New York, and separate the cinematic fiction from the physical geography.

The Geographic Heart: Amityville, New York

At its core, Amityville is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) located in Suffolk County, on the South Shore of Long Island, New York. When people ask "where is Amityville Island," they are typically referring to this specific community. It is not an island in the traditional sense of being surrounded by water on all sides, but rather a mainland settlement situated on the southwestern edge of Long Island, directly bordering the Atlantic Ocean.

Coordinates and Precise Location

For precision, the geographic center of Amityville is located at approximately 40°41′28″N 73°31′06″W. The hamlet sits on the south shore of Long Island, with the Village of Babylon to its west and the hamlet of East Massapequa to its east. Its southern boundary is the Atlantic Ocean, and to the north, it is bordered by the Nassau County line, specifically the Village of Island Trees.

AD
Amityville Long Island 2011- 2012 with 50th High School Reunion
Amityville Long Island 2011- 2012 with 50th High School Reunion
an old black and white photo of airplanes flying in the sky over houses with trees
an old black and white photo of airplanes flying in the sky over houses with trees
Amityville Long Island Photos of 2013
Amityville Long Island Photos of 2013

The Barrier Island: Assatague Island

The confusion regarding an "island" in the name stems from the location's proximity to Assateague Island. While Amityville itself is on Long Island, the name "Amityville" is believed to have been derived from the Shinnecock Indian Nation's name for the area. However, the modern association with "island" is heavily reinforced by the 1979 film, which was set in a fictionalized version of this community. The actual location used for the famous television movie was primarily on the mainland, though the story's setting implies a barrier island existence.

The Setting: A Community on the Water

Amityville is defined by its coastal geography. It is a community where the land meets the sea, characterized by sandy beaches, inlets, and the constant presence of the Atlantic Ocean. The main commercial strip, Riverhead Avenue, runs parallel to the water, offering residents and visitors views of the bay and the open ocean. The area is known for its fishing industry, maritime history, and the distinct salt-air atmosphere that defines South Shore Long Island.

The Amityville Horror House In New York Will Give You Nightmares
The Amityville Horror House In New York Will Give You Nightmares
Inside the ‘Amityville Horror’ house today, Long Island’s most notorious mansion
Inside the ‘Amityville Horror’ house today, Long Island’s most notorious mansion
Americans Are Sharing Very, Very, Very Dark True Crime Stories From Their Hometowns, And It's Quite Alarming
Americans Are Sharing Very, Very, Very Dark True Crime Stories From Their Hometowns, And It's Quite Alarming

Beyond the Myth: Modern Amityville

Today, Amityville is a functioning suburban community with a population of over 9,000 residents. It operates as a vital part of the Suffolk County economy, featuring a mix of residential neighborhoods, small businesses, and public amenities. The legacy of the 1979 film remains a cultural touchstone, attracting tourists and paranormal enthusiasts, but the town itself is a place of ordinary life, where people live, work, and raise families away from the sensationalized horror narrative.

Navigating to the Location

For those seeking the physical location, navigation is straightforward. Amityville is easily accessible via major roadways, including the Heckscher State Parkway and the Southern State Parkway. It is approximately 50 miles east of Manhattan and 10 miles west of Montauk. The LIRR (Long Island Rail Road) provides direct service to the Amityville Station, making it a convenient destination for those looking to explore the real place behind the legend.

AD
Amityville
Amityville
Amityville house - The Haunted House With Real Facts
Amityville house - The Haunted House With Real Facts
The Amityville Myth
The Amityville Myth
a large white house sitting on the side of a road in front of some trees
a large white house sitting on the side of a road in front of some trees
Most Popular Crazy Facts About Long Island
Most Popular Crazy Facts About Long Island
an old black and white photo of a large house with two balconies on the roof
an old black and white photo of a large house with two balconies on the roof
Amity Island: One fan's pilgrimage to 'Jaws' shooting location Martha's Vineyard — The Daily Jaws
Amity Island: One fan's pilgrimage to 'Jaws' shooting location Martha's Vineyard — The Daily Jaws
Slaying of family in spooky Long Island house inspired ‘The Amityville Horror’
Slaying of family in spooky Long Island house inspired ‘The Amityville Horror’
Inside the Amityville house of horrors 45 years after family murder
Inside the Amityville house of horrors 45 years after family murder
a large white house sitting on top of a lush green hillside next to a lake
a large white house sitting on top of a lush green hillside next to a lake
Amytiville Ocean Avenue 112
Amytiville Ocean Avenue 112
a boat is parked in front of a house on the water's edge near a dock
a boat is parked in front of a house on the water's edge near a dock
an old advertisement for a house with pictures on it
an old advertisement for a house with pictures on it
a motorcyclist is driving down the street in front of some houses with american flags on them
a motorcyclist is driving down the street in front of some houses with american flags on them
Inside Amityville Horror House Today - Story That Terrified America
Inside Amityville Horror House Today - Story That Terrified America
Long Island's Amityville Horror house is being bought
Long Island's Amityville Horror house is being bought
Do you dare to live here? 'Amityville Horror' home is for sale
Do you dare to live here? 'Amityville Horror' home is for sale
Amityville Horror House - The Scene Of The 1974 DeFeo Murders
Amityville Horror House - The Scene Of The 1974 DeFeo Murders
an old house with white trim and black shutters
an old house with white trim and black shutters
before and after photos of a house in the 1950's and now on display
before and after photos of a house in the 1950's and now on display
AD