Top Rated Mattresses 2017: Best Picks for Quality Sleep
Selecting the right mattress in 2017 meant navigating a market saturated with new materials, advanced sleep-tracking technology, and an overwhelming variety of feel options. This guide cuts through the noise to highlight the top-rated mattresses that defined the year, focusing on models that consistently delivered on comfort, support, and value. The goal is to provide a clear, unbiased overview to help you understand what made specific models stand out in a competitive landscape.
The Evolution of Mattress Design in 2017
By 2017, the mattress industry had moved far beyond the innerspring vs. foam binary. Consumers were demanding personalized comfort, leading to a surge in hybrid models that combined the responsive support of pocketed coils with the pressure-relieving properties of memory foam or latex. The top-rated mattresses of the year were almost exclusively hybrids, designed to offer the best of both worlds. This shift reflected a broader industry trend, where trial periods were extended, and mattress-in-a-box delivery became the standard, making high-quality sleep more accessible than ever before.
Key Performance Factors for 2017
When evaluating the top-rated mattresses of 2017, several criteria separated the good from the truly great. Motion isolation was critical for couples, ensuring that one partner's movements did not disturb the other. Temperature regulation was another major focus, with many leading brands incorporating gel infusions, graphite, and phase-change materials to combat the traditional heat retention issues of memory foam. Durability was assessed through construction quality, particularly the gauge of the coil system and the density of the foam layers, which directly impacted the mattress's lifespan.
Top Contenders and Their Strengths
The landscape of top-rated mattresses in 2017 was dominated by a few key players, each with a distinct identity. The best options excelled in specific areas, whether it was providing a plush, cradling sensation or a firmer, more supportive base. Below is a look at the models that consistently topped independent reviews and consumer reports during that period.
| Mattress | Primary Feel | Key Feature | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Layla Memory Foam | Soft & Contouring | Copper-infused foam for temperature control | Side Sleepers, Budget-Conscious |
| Brooklyn Aurora | Medium-Firm | Advanced foam encasement for edge support | Combination Sleepers, Hot Sleepers |
| WinkBed | Firm & Supportive | Micro-coil support layer with foam comfort | Back Sleepers, Heavy Individuals |
Layla Memory Foam
The Layla mattress carved out a niche in 2017 with its innovative dual-firmness design, allowing sleepers to choose between a soft side and a firm side by simply flipping the mattress. It utilized copper-infused memory foam, a relatively new trend at the time, which actively worked to draw heat away from the body. This model was rated highly for its ability to relieve pressure points without sacrificing too much support, making it an excellent choice for side sleepers and couples looking for affordability without compromising on quality.
Brooklyn Aurora
The Brooklyn Aurora represented the premium end of the foam mattress spectrum. It featured a sophisticated construction with multiple foam layers, including a top layer infused with graphite and charcoal to actively manage sleep temperature. Reviewers praised its exceptional edge support, a common weakness in foam mattresses, which allowed for nearly full use of the sleeping surface. This mattress was a top rating for those who preferred a lighter, more breathable foam that didn’t feel "stuck" to the bed.
Value and Lifestyle Considerations
Beyond pure performance, the best mattress in 2017 was evaluated on its ability to fit a modern lifestyle. The mattress-in-a-box revolution was in full swing, offering free shipping, risk-free trial periods often lasting 100 nights or more, and straightforward return processes. This shift democratized access to high-quality sleep, allowing consumers to test premium materials like Talalay latex and individually wrapped coils without the financial commitment of a traditional showroom purchase. The value was not just in the price tag but in the confidence provided by these generous policies.
Looking Ahead: The Legacy of 2017
The mattresses that earned top ratings in 2017 set the standard for the industry, influencing designs and materials for years to come. The emphasis on hybrid technology, temperature neutrality, and robust trial periods defined the modern sleep experience. While specific models may have been updated or replaced, the core principles established during that period—durability, personalized comfort, and ethical business practices—remain the benchmark for anyone in the market for a good night's sleep. Understanding these benchmarks is key to finding a mattress that truly supports your body and lifestyle.