replacing an old toilet

Effortless Guide: Replacing an Old Toilet & Best Models 2024

By
AD

Few home projects offer the same sense of instant transformation as replacing an old toilet. What was once a shaky, noisy fixture that never quite flushed correctly becomes a modern, efficient unit that operates quietly and reliably. This process is less about complex plumbing wizardry and more about careful preparation and methodical execution.

The Compelling Case for Replacement

Beyond aesthetic upgrades, replacing an outdated toilet is often a practical necessity driven by performance and efficiency. Older models manufactured before the 1990s typically consume significantly more water per flush, leading to higher utility bills over the lifespan of the unit. Modern toilets are engineered with dual-flush systems or pressure-assisted mechanisms that use a fraction of the water while providing superior flushing power.

Signs Your Current Toilet Needs Replacement

Knowing when to replace rather than repair is a crucial first step. Persistent clogging, constant running water, or visible cracks in the porcelain are clear indicators that a replacement is necessary. Furthermore, if you are undertaking a full bathroom remodel, ensuring that the toilet aligns with the new layout, style, and floor plan is essential for a cohesive final result.

AD
How to Remove an Old Toilet and Install a New One
How to Remove an Old Toilet and Install a New One
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!
The Dos and Don’ts of Replacing a Toilet
The Dos and Don’ts of Replacing a Toilet

Preparation and Safety Protocols

Successful installation begins long before the new unit touches the floor. Safety and preparation are paramount to avoid damage to the bathroom and ensure a smooth workflow. You must prioritize shutting off the water supply and draining the tank and bowl completely to prevent messy and potentially hazardous spills during the removal process.

Additionally, gathering the right tools and materials beforehand prevents the frustration of mid-project trips to the hardware store. You will need a heavy-duty wrench, a putty knife, a bucket, a new wax seal, and potentially a pair of channel-lock pliers. Wearing gloves and eye protection is highly recommended to protect against residual bacteria and debris.

How To Replace A Toilet - Penny Pinchin' Mom
How To Replace A Toilet - Penny Pinchin' Mom
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How to Remove an Old Toilet and Install a New One
How to Remove an Old Toilet and Install a New One

Step-by-Step Removal Process

Removing the old toilet is the most physically demanding part of the project, requiring a methodical approach to avoid cracking the porcelain.

  • Turn off the water supply valve and flush the toilet to empty the tank and bowl.
  • Disconnect the water supply line from the tank using a wrench.
  • Remove the caps covering the bolts securing the toilet to the floor.
  • Use the wrench to loosen and remove the nuts and bolts.
  • Carefully rock the bowl slightly from side to side to break the seal of the wax ring, then lift it straight up.
  • Clean the residual wax and debris from the closet flange and the floor.

Installing the New Unit

With the old unit removed and the area cleaned, you can proceed with installing the new toilet. The critical element here is the wax seal, which creates a waterproof barrier between the base of the toilet and the drain pipe. Proper placement of this seal is essential to prevent future leaks.

AD

Before setting the bowl, you should test the fit of the new seat and lid to ensure compatibility. Once the wax ring is firmly seated on the waste outlet, gently lower the bowl onto the seal, aligning the bolt holes with the floor mounting holes. Apply steady, even pressure without sliding the bowl, as this can break the wax seal.

How to Remove a Toilet, and Replace it Yourself | Ron Hazelton
How to Remove a Toilet, and Replace it Yourself | Ron Hazelton
How to Replace a Toilet | Easy DIY Bathroom Project
How to Replace a Toilet | Easy DIY Bathroom Project
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How To Replace a Toilet Like a Pro (DIY)
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!
How to Remove a Toilet Yourself: Stop Paying for Plumbers!
Replacing A Toilet Is Easy And Quick, Check Out Our Step By Step Tutorial
Replacing A Toilet Is Easy And Quick, Check Out Our Step By Step Tutorial
a white toilet sitting in a bathroom next to a bath tub
a white toilet sitting in a bathroom next to a bath tub

Securing and Connecting

After positioning the bowl, you must secure it firmly to the floor to prevent any future movement or rocking.

StepAction
1Place the toilet bowl onto the wax seal, aligning the bolts.
2Press down firmly, ensuring the seal is not compromised.
3Secure the bowl with nuts and washers, tightening them alternately.
4Reconnect the water supply line to the tank's fill valve.
5Turn the water supply back on and allow the tank to fill.

It is vital not to overtighten the bolts, as this can crack the toilet base. A snug fit is sufficient. Once the tank is filled, check the base of the toilet and the floor around it for any signs of leakage. Running the flush cycle while observing the connection points is the best way to confirm a perfect seal.

AD

Final Adjustments and Testing

The final phase involves ensuring the toilet functions correctly and complements the bathroom space. After confirming there are no leaks, you should check the bowl's position in relation to the floor and the surrounding fixtures. It should sit level and feel solid under pressure.

DIY Toilet Replacement Tips for Women
DIY Toilet Replacement Tips for Women
How to Replace a Toilet Seat
How to Replace a Toilet Seat
Toilet Repairs - Part 2 - Replacing the Fill Valve
Toilet Repairs - Part 2 - Replacing the Fill Valve
How to Replace, Repair & Re-attach Your Toilet
How to Replace, Repair & Re-attach Your Toilet
How To Get Rid Of Old Toilet – Storables
How To Get Rid Of Old Toilet – Storables
How To Fix A Rocking Toilet | Young House Love
How To Fix A Rocking Toilet | Young House Love
a white toilet sitting in a bathroom next to a wall with mushrooms on it and the words how to remove a toilet
a white toilet sitting in a bathroom next to a wall with mushrooms on it and the words how to remove a toilet
a man sitting on top of a toilet in a bathroom next to a red bucket
a man sitting on top of a toilet in a bathroom next to a red bucket
How to Install a Toilet: The Easy Way
How to Install a Toilet: The Easy Way
Replacing A Toilet Flush Lever in 3 Quick And Easy Steps — TruBuild Construction
Replacing A Toilet Flush Lever in 3 Quick And Easy Steps — TruBuild Construction
Bathrooms
Bathrooms
Easy Steps for Removing a Toilet
Easy Steps for Removing a Toilet
How to Replace a Toilet - Fine Homebuilding
How to Replace a Toilet - Fine Homebuilding
How to Replace a Toilet
How to Replace a Toilet

Take a moment to adjust the water level in the tank if the bowl is not flushing completely. Most modern toilets have an adjustment screw or a float valve that can be tweaked to optimize the water volume. Once everything is calibrated, you can consider the installation complete.

AD