Kitchen Trends to Avoid in 2019: Outdated Designs for a Modern Home
Looking back at 2019, the kitchen was a space of bold experimentation, but not every trend proved to be a wise investment. While some innovations promised to elevate the heart of the home, others quickly revealed themselves as impractical fads that created more work than joy. Understanding these missteps is crucial for anyone planning a renovation, as it allows you to differentiate between lasting design principles and short-lived obsessions that can clutter your space and your budget.
Open-Concept Appliance Islands
The push to make the kitchen the undeniable center of the home led many to embrace the appliance island—a rolling cart laden with a microwave, air fryer, or secondary refrigerator. In theory, it offered flexibility and social connectivity, but in practice, it became a cluttered eyesore. By 2019, designers noted that these islands often turned the cooking zone into a chaotic pantry, forcing homeowners to choose between sacrificing precious counter space or navigating a minefield of cords and handles. The trend diluted the functionality of the primary work triangle, making the kitchen feel disorganized rather than expansive.
The Drawbacks of Cluttered Countertops
Keeping small appliances on display created a constant visual mess that required daily management. The "island" frequently became a dumping ground for mail, school projects, and half-finished coffee cups, undermining the very cleanliness that a kitchen remodel aims to achieve. Furthermore, these items competed for essential real estate, crowding out the space needed for actual meal preparation. Instead of enhancing workflow, the appliance island often created a bottleneck where multiple people couldn't comfortably work side-by-side without getting in each other's way.
Overly Trendy Color Palettes
2019 was the year of the bold kitchen, with homeowners diving headfirst into specific color trends like millennial pink, forest green, and even black kitchen cabinets. While these shades can look stunning in show homes with perfect lighting, they often date a space rapidly. Design professionals warned against committing to a trendy hue for what is typically the longest-lasting element of a room. A shade that feels fresh and exciting one year can feel dated and overwhelming just 12 months later, making the space feel dated before the paint has even dried.
Choosing Timeless Over Trendy
Instead of following the color of the season, interior experts advocated for grounding the kitchen in classic neutrals for large surfaces. White, gray, and natural wood provide a timeless backdrop that allows vibrant textiles, artwork, or a single feature wall to shine without the pressure of a fleeting trend. If a bold color is irresistible, the safer approach is to incorporate it through removable decals, cabinet interiors, or accent walls that can be easily changed when the trend fades. This strategy protects your investment and ensures the space remains versatile and market-friendly.
Another significant misstep was the widespread installation of oversized, floor-to-ceiling open shelving. Driven by the desire for airy, Pinterest-perfect aesthetics, many homeowners eliminated cabinet doors entirely. However, by 2019, it was clear that this layout was a high-maintenance nightmare. Every pan, pot, and cooking tool was on constant display, meaning that a quick week of normal cooking resulted in a chaotic visual mess. Dusting became a daily chore, and the lack of concealment for utilitarian items stripped the room of its cozy, lived-in charm.
Embracing the Hybrid Approach
The solution that gained traction was the hybrid kitchen, which strategically mixes open shelving with traditional closed cabinetry. Designers suggested keeping everyday dishes and frequently used appliances behind doors to maintain a clean look, while using open shelves to display beautiful dishware or house items you actually use daily. This balanced approach offers the visual lightness of the trend while retaining the practical benefits of concealed storage, preventing the kitchen from feeling like a sterile display case rather than a functional workspace.
Textured subway tile, particularly in ornate, Victorian-style patterns, saw a surge in popularity in 2019. While intended to add character and vintage appeal, these intricate designs often proved difficult to clean. The multiple grooves and raised patterns caught greasy splatters, dust, and soap residue, turning a simple wipe-down into a tedious, time-consuming process. What was meant to be a charming detail quickly became a source of frustration, highlighting that aesthetic appeal must sometimes be sacrificed for practical maintenance.
Opting for Cleaner Lines
In response, 2019 saw a shift toward simpler, more streamlined materials that offered the same visual impact with less effort. Homeowners began to favor classic, rectangular subway tile with minimal grout lines or large-format porcelain slabs that mimicked the look without the cleaning ordeal. This move reflected a more mature understanding of design: a kitchen is a high-use area where easy maintenance is just as important as visual appeal. Choosing materials that can withstand the test of both time and dish soap is a hallmark of smart, sustainable design.