is 1847 rogers bros silverware real silver

Is 1847 Rogers Bros Silverware Real Silver? Spot the Difference!

By
AD

When you discover a vintage serving spoon in your grandmother's drawer stamped "1847 Rogers Bros," the immediate question is almost always the same: is this genuine sterling silver or merely silverplate? The short answer is that 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware is not real sterling silver in the traditional sense, but rather an extremely high-quality and historically significant form of silverplate that commands respect and value in the antique market.

Understanding the 1847 Rogers Brothers Legacy

The story begins not in 1847, but in the 1840s, when the Rogers brothers—William, Henry, and Simeon—started their journey in the United States. They founded what would become one of the most prestigious names in American silverware, Rogers Brothers. However, the specific year 1847 is less a manufacturing date and more a symbolic reference point often used in branding to evoke the company's deep historical roots and commitment to the craftsmanship of that era. Their primary production facility was located in Hartford, Connecticut, a hub for American industry.

Sterling Silver vs. Silverplate: The Critical Distinction

To determine the composition of 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware, one must understand the difference between sterling silver and silverplate. Sterling silver is an alloy containing 92.5% pure silver and 7.5% other metals, usually copper, for durability. Items made of sterling silver are typically marked with "925," ".925," or the word "Sterling." In contrast, silverplate involves bonding a thin layer of silver onto a base metal, such as copper or brass, through an electroplating process. While 1847 Rogers Bros. pieces contain silver, they do not meet the strict alloy standard required to be called sterling silver. They are, instead, a premium form of silverplate.

AD
Roy Roger's Unisex Dinnerware
Roy Roger's Unisex Dinnerware
1874 Rogers Bros Centennial Silver Plate By International Silver (1970s)
1874 Rogers Bros Centennial Silver Plate By International Silver (1970s)
1938 PAPER AD 1847 Rogers Bros Silverware Ambassador Legacy Her Majesty Design | eBay
1938 PAPER AD 1847 Rogers Bros Silverware Ambassador Legacy Her Majesty Design | eBay

The Quality of Rogers Silverplate

Not all silverplate is created equal, and this is where Rogers Brothers distinguished itself. The company did not use a cheap, thin layer of silver that would wear off quickly. Instead, they employed a heavy electroplating process, resulting in a substantial layer of silver that could be many times thicker than standard decorative plating. This commitment to quality means that 1847 Rogers Bros. items have a much longer lifespan and a more valuable appearance than lesser silverplate, often surviving for over a century with proper care.

Identifying Your Silverware: Marks and Hallmarks

Authenticating your 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware requires a careful examination of the markings. While the phrase "1847 Rogers Bros." is common, the actual marks changed significantly over the company's long history, which spans from the 19th century into the 20th. You are unlikely to find a piece of genuine antique silverware stamped simply with "1847." Instead, look for the official Rogers Brothers hallmark, which often features the words "Rogers Bros." surrounded by other identifying symbols, date letters, or a copyright notice like "Registered." These marks are crucial for confirming the item's origin and age.

1847 Rogers Bros Flair 38-Piece Silverplate Flatware Set in Original Wood Chest
1847 Rogers Bros Flair 38-Piece Silverplate Flatware Set in Original Wood Chest
Rogers Bros Dining | 76 Pc Atiq/Vtg 1847 Rogers Bros Silverplate Set Plus | Color: Brown/Silver | Size: Os
Rogers Bros Dining | 76 Pc Atiq/Vtg 1847 Rogers Bros Silverplate Set Plus | Color: Brown/Silver | Size: Os
WM. A Rogers AI Plus Oneida Silver Plate Dinner Forks Lot of 6
WM. A Rogers AI Plus Oneida Silver Plate Dinner Forks Lot of 6
Marking Example Era Composition
Rogers Bros. A1 Early-Mid 20th Century Heavy Silverplate
1847 Rogers Bros. logo Late 20th Century Reproduction Standard Silverplate
Rogers International Modern Era Varies

Value and Collectibility

The value of 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware is determined not by its silver melt value, but by its collectibility, condition, and historical significance. Because it is silverplate, it does not carry the high intrinsic metal value of sterling silver. However, high-quality Rogers pieces are highly sought after by antique enthusiasts and collectors. Items featuring intricate patterns like "Durant," "Panama," or "Candlewick" are particularly prized. The brand's reputation for durability and timeless design ensures that these pieces remain desirable and retain substantial monetary and sentimental value.

Caring for Your Vintage Silverplate

Whether you are a new owner or a prospective buyer, proper care is essential to maintain the beauty of 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware. Because the silver layer is relatively thick, these items are quite durable but still require attention. Avoid harsh abrasive cleaners like baking soda, which can strip the silver layer. Instead, use gentle, phosphate-free soaps and warm water. For tougher tarnish, a specialized silver-polishing cloth is recommended. Never use the dishwasher, as the harsh detergents and high heat can damage the plating and the base metal over time.

AD

Modern Reproductions and the Market Today

It is important to be aware that "1847 Rogers Bros." is a popular marking found on many modern reproductions and souvenir items sold in gift shops today. These contemporary pieces are mass-produced and lack the historical integrity and heavy plating of the original antique items. When shopping for genuine 1847 Rogers Bros. silverware, stick to reputable antique dealers, online marketplaces with strong buyer protection, and estate sales. Look for the weight heft and the quality of the finish, as these are indicators of the superior craftsmanship of the original pieces.

Top 5 Most Valuable 1847 Rogers Bros Silverware Sets: Prices and Identification Guide (Up to $3,400)
Top 5 Most Valuable 1847 Rogers Bros Silverware Sets: Prices and Identification Guide (Up to $3,400)
an antique silver fork with ornate designs on the handles and sides, set against a plain white background
an antique silver fork with ornate designs on the handles and sides, set against a plain white background
First Love 1847 Rogers Bros silver plate flatware, vintage silverware in box
First Love 1847 Rogers Bros silver plate flatware, vintage silverware in box
an advertisement for roger's bros from the early 1900's, featuring spoons and
an advertisement for roger's bros from the early 1900's, featuring spoons and
Gorham Silver Melrose (Sterling,1948, No Monograms) 4 Piece Dinner Size Setting - Silverware
Gorham Silver Melrose (Sterling,1948, No Monograms) 4 Piece Dinner Size Setting - Silverware
Lot 7 x 1847 Rogers VINTAGE Grape Pattern Silver Plate 7 1/2" Dinner FORKS
Lot 7 x 1847 Rogers VINTAGE Grape Pattern Silver Plate 7 1/2" Dinner FORKS
King Richard by Towle Sterling Silver Flatware Set 12 Service 87 Pcs Dinner Size
King Richard by Towle Sterling Silver Flatware Set 12 Service 87 Pcs Dinner Size
Francis I Sterling Silver Set of 12 Butter or Appetizer Knives by Reed & Barton
Francis I Sterling Silver Set of 12 Butter or Appetizer Knives by Reed & Barton
ad eBay | $14.00 | 1847 Rogers Silverplate IS Remembrance Serving Spoons Set of 2 Flatware | Antique
ad eBay | $14.00 | 1847 Rogers Silverplate IS Remembrance Serving Spoons Set of 2 Flatware | Antique
Rogers Bro Dining | Vintage Silverware | Color: Silver | Size: Os
Rogers Bro Dining | Vintage Silverware | Color: Silver | Size: Os
Vintage 1847 Roger's Bros Heritage "IS" Inlaid Silver Salad Forks (6.75" x 1 1/8") 1.3oz 1 of 8
Vintage 1847 Roger's Bros Heritage "IS" Inlaid Silver Salad Forks (6.75" x 1 1/8") 1.3oz 1 of 8
Silverplate Patterns - HERITAGE 1953 by 1847 Rogers Bros.
Silverplate Patterns - HERITAGE 1953 by 1847 Rogers Bros.
Kijiji - Buy, Sell & Save with Canada's #1 Local Classifieds
Kijiji - Buy, Sell & Save with Canada's #1 Local Classifieds
So what or who is “1847 Rogers Bros”? revised 9/27/25
So what or who is “1847 Rogers Bros”? revised 9/27/25
1847 Rogers Bros Flair Silver Plated Flatware Set, 56pc - Etsy
1847 Rogers Bros Flair Silver Plated Flatware Set, 56pc - Etsy
1980s Silver Dessert/Salad Fork, Royal York
1980s Silver Dessert/Salad Fork, Royal York
an assortment of silverware including forks, knives and spoons
an assortment of silverware including forks, knives and spoons
AD