The Ultimate Guide to Replacing Siding with Brick: DIY Tips & Costs
Replacing siding with brick is one of the most impactful decisions a homeowner can make to elevate curb appeal and long-term property value. While the project requires a significant investment of time and capital, the structural durability and classic aesthetic of brick are difficult to match by any other exterior material. This guide walks you through the entire process, from initial planning to final cleanup, ensuring you understand the scope, costs, and critical considerations before breaking ground.
Understanding the Scope and Complexity
Before you contact contractors, it is essential to recognize that installing brick over existing siding is not a simple siding replacement; it is a hybrid cladding project. Unlike a tear-off, where old material is removed, brick veneer requires the existing substrate to be perfectly flat, dry, and structurally sound. The brick itself is not a structural element but a decorative skin that adds significant weight—up to 15 pounds per square foot—to the exterior walls. This load must be properly transferred to the structure, usually through metal ties that anchor the brick to the studs behind the old siding. Failure to address this structural requirement can lead to cracking, detachment, or wall failure, making engineering a non-negotiable part of the planning phase.
Is Tear-Off Always Necessary?
In most standard scenarios, keeping the old siding in place is not recommended and is often prohibited by modern building codes. Siding materials like vinyl or fiber-cement can prevent the new brick from adhering correctly to the sheathing. More importantly, hidden problems such as rot, mold, or insect damage can fester beneath the brick surface if the old material is not removed. While there are rare instances where conditions are perfect—such as solid wood shingle in excellent condition—a professional will generally insist on a full tear-off to ensure a safe, flat, and dry substrate. This step, though adding to the labor cost, is crucial for the longevity and integrity of the wall system.
Budgeting for the Transformation
Cost is the primary variable that dictates the pace of your project, and brick installation is no exception. Because this is a labor-intensive process involving masons, carpenters, and potentially engineers, labor costs typically dwarf the price of the materials themselves. You should anticipate spending significantly more per square foot than you would for a basic vinyl replacement. Beyond the brick and labor, you must factor in the costs of concrete footings, wall ties, drip caps, flashing, and mortar. It is highly advisable to obtain at least three detailed quotes from licensed contractors. These bids should break down line items, allowing you to compare not just the total price but the specific scope of work each company intends to perform.
| Cost Factor | Impact on Budget |
|---|---|
| Type of Brick | Real handmade brick can cost double or triple that of extruded thin brick. |
| Wall Condition | Rotted sheathing or structural repairs can add thousands to the total cost. |
| Mortar Color and Pattern | Complex patterns like herringbone or basketweave require more planning and time. |
| Accessibility | High walls or difficult terrain may require scaffolding, increasing labor rates. |
The Professional Installation Process
Assuming the old siding has been removed and the sheathing inspected, the physical installation follows a strict sequence that requires precision. The process begins with affixing a weather-resistive barrier (WRB) like tar paper or housewrap to the sheathing, creating a second line of defense against moisture. Next, a plastic drainage plane, or Z-flashing, is installed at the base of the wall to direct any water that penetrates the mortar joints safely downward. The brick is then laid, starting from the bottom, using a spirit level to ensure each course is perfectly straight. Stainless steel ties are spaced every 16 inches to bind the brick to the wall, and full mortar joints—not just a skim coat—are essential to ensure the system moves as one cohesive unit.
Material Selection and Aesthetics
Choosing the right brick is about balancing visual preference with practical application. If your goal is a historic restoration, you might seek out salvage yards to find matching units. For new construction or modernization, contemporary thin brick offers the look of traditional masonry with a fraction of the weight and cost. Regardless of your choice, the color and texture must complement your roofline, windows, and landscape. Consider how the brick will age; while most bricks fade minimally, the mortar joints will weather. Using a darker mortar color can hide dirt and streaks better over time, keeping the facade looking sharp with less maintenance.
Navigating Permits and Weather Delays
Before the first shovel hits the ground, securing the necessary permits is mandatory. You will likely need authorization from the local building department, which will require detailed plans demonstrating that the load calculations are correct and that the work complies with energy codes. During the permitting process, do not ignore seasonal timing. Masonry work is highly dependent on temperature. Most types of mortar cannot be applied if the temperature is below freezing or if rain is expected within the next 24 hours. A rushed job in poor weather results in weak joints that crumble, leading to expensive repairs down the line. Planning for a dry, mild window is essential to keep the project on schedule.
Post-Installation Considerations
Once the masons have cleaned the excess mortar from the joints—known as tooling—your work is far from over. You must account for the inevitable debris removal. Demolishing old siding, hauling it to a landfill, and cleaning the resulting dust and debris from the landscape can take just as long as the installation itself. Additionally, inspect the caulking around windows, doors, and where the brick meets the foundation. Proper caulking is the final defense against water intrusion. Finally, while brick requires minimal upkeep, you should periodically check the mortar joints for "spalling" or erosion. Re-pointing the joints every 20 to 30 years is a simple maintenance task that preserves the entire assembly and ensures your investment lasts for generations.