how to measure shortening

The Ultimate Guide to Measuring Shortening Perfectly Every Time

By
AD

Measuring shortening accurately is a fundamental skill for any baker, yet it is a step often performed intuitively or with frustration. Unlike liquids, which settle level in a measuring cup, shortening has a texture similar to soft soap or dense clay, making it challenging to gauge without the right technique. Furthermore, most modern recipes assume the standard US measurement system, where shortening is measured by volume, even though professional bakers often prefer weight for precision.

The Science Behind Shortening Measurement

Before diving into the how-to, it helps to understand the why. Shortening is an aerated fat; incorporating air during the creaming process is essential for creating a tender crumb in cakes. When you scoop directly from the container, you risk packing the product tightly. Packed shortening yields less volume during mixing, which can result in a dense, heavy final product because the necessary amount of air is not introduced.

The Spoon and Level Method

This is the most reliable method for home bakers using volume measurements. The goal is to avoid compression from the start. Instead of pressing the shortening into the measuring cup, you allow it to sit loosely. Follow these steps: First, use a spoon to gently scoop the shortening from the tub. Fill the measuring cup heaping full, ensuring there is enough excess to level off. Finally, take the straight edge of a knife or spatula and scrape across the top of the measuring cup to remove the excess, leaving a perfectly level surface.

AD
How to Measure Shortening
How to Measure Shortening
Learn How To Measure Shortening
Learn How To Measure Shortening
The Quick Tip for Using Shortening
The Quick Tip for Using Shortening

Alternative Methods for Specific Needs

While the spoon and level method works well for most scenarios, specific circumstances may require alternative approaches. Whether you are dealing with a greasy kitchen, a recipe that demands speed, or a need for absolute precision, there are distinct paths to measuring success.

The Water Displacement Method

This technique is excellent for minimizing waste and ensuring accuracy, particularly when dealing with sticky ingredients. It utilizes the principle that oil and water do not mix. Start by pouring water into a liquid measuring cup—use a quantity greater than the amount of shortening you need. For instance, if you need one cup of shortening, pour one and a half cups of water into the cup. Next, add spoonfuls of shortening into the water until the water level rises to the one-cup mark. The shortening that has been added equates exactly to the volume you require. Finally, drain the water, and you have your measured shortening ready to mix.

Do You Know the Right Way to Measure Shortening?
Do You Know the Right Way to Measure Shortening?
How To Grease A Bundt Pan (2 Ways!)
How To Grease A Bundt Pan (2 Ways!)
How to Easily Measure Shortening
How to Easily Measure Shortening

The Package Method and Weight Measurement

For ultimate consistency, moving to weight is highly recommended. Kitchen scales remove the variability of volume entirely. Many shortening brands, such as Crisco, sell their product in pre-measured sticks similar to butter, with markings indicating tablespoons and cups. If a recipe calls for one cup, you can simply cut the required amount from the box. Using a scale is the professional standard; zero out your bowl, place the shortening container on it, and tare the scale. Add shortening until the display shows the exact weight specified in grams or ounces called for in the recipe.

Avoiding Common Pitfalls

Even experienced bakers can slip into habits that compromise their measurements. One frequent error is attempting to measure shortening in a dry measuring cup by pressing it down. This action compacts the fat, resulting in significantly more fat than the recipe intends. This is why the spoon and level method is superior; it measures the natural volume of the product. Another pitfall is measuring over a mixing bowl, which leads to messy countertops and potentially contaminated shortening if drops are knocked back into the tub.

AD

Conversion and Practical Tips

For the sake of efficiency in the kitchen, understanding standard conversions is vital. Generally, one US cup of shortening is equivalent to 225 grams or approximately 8 ounces. If a recipe comes from a European source, you might find it easier to weigh the product from the start, as metric measurements are standard there. When working with partially used tubs, resist the urge to guess. A visual inspection for estimating is unreliable; fats compress over time, and the appearance of fullness does not equate to a full cup of baking potential.

a kitchen scale with some food on it next to a measuring spoon and jar of yogurt
a kitchen scale with some food on it next to a measuring spoon and jar of yogurt
Measuring Shortening (Crisco)
Measuring Shortening (Crisco)
How to Measure Shortening without a Sticky Mess | Walking on Sunshine
How to Measure Shortening without a Sticky Mess | Walking on Sunshine
a scale with some food on top of it next to a blender and bag of flour
a scale with some food on top of it next to a blender and bag of flour
How to Measure Ingredients for Better Baking
How to Measure Ingredients for Better Baking
four different types of food are shown in this graphic above the instructions for how to make an appetizer
four different types of food are shown in this graphic above the instructions for how to make an appetizer
The Easiest Way to Measure Shortening - Housewife Eclectic
The Easiest Way to Measure Shortening - Housewife Eclectic
No Mess Way to EASILY and ACCURATELY Measure Solid Shortening, Butter, or Margarine
No Mess Way to EASILY and ACCURATELY Measure Solid Shortening, Butter, or Margarine
Hundred-Year-Old Directions for Measuring a Spoonful of Shortening
Hundred-Year-Old Directions for Measuring a Spoonful of Shortening
the table shows how many different types of vegetables have been added to each individual portion
the table shows how many different types of vegetables have been added to each individual portion
Hacks For How To Measure Butter, Shortening & Ingredients // Lindsay Ann Bakes
Hacks For How To Measure Butter, Shortening & Ingredients // Lindsay Ann Bakes
Can I Substitute Shortening for Butter? (Or the Other Way Around?)
Can I Substitute Shortening for Butter? (Or the Other Way Around?)
No Mess Way to EASILY and ACCURATELY Measure Solid Shortening, Butter, or Margarine
No Mess Way to EASILY and ACCURATELY Measure Solid Shortening, Butter, or Margarine
Difference Between Butter and Shortening
Difference Between Butter and Shortening
Shortening cup us to lb converter for culinary teaching and diet.
Shortening cup us to lb converter for culinary teaching and diet.
measuring flour on top of a scale with the words how to measure flour in front of it
measuring flour on top of a scale with the words how to measure flour in front of it
What Is Shortening? — Food Network
What Is Shortening? — Food Network
a person using a spatula to dip cream into a bowl on a cutting board
a person using a spatula to dip cream into a bowl on a cutting board
The Best Shortening Substitutes
The Best Shortening Substitutes
AD