cedartone vs cedar

Cedartone vs Cedar: The Ultimate Showdown for Tone & Durability

By
AD

At first glance, the terms cedartone and cedar might appear interchangeable, particularly to those navigating the world of boutique guitar pedals or fine woodworking. However, a closer inspection reveals a fundamental distinction that impacts tone, application, and material value. Understanding the difference is essential for musicians seeking the perfect overdrive and for craftspeople evaluating wood for a project, as the confusion often leads to misinformed purchases and unmet expectations.

The Nature of Cedar as a Material

Cedar is a specific genus of coniferous tree, most notably the Western Red Cedar (Thuja plicata) and Spanish Cedar (Cedrela odorata). In the context of musical instruments and acoustic applications, cedar usually refers to the soft, aromatic wood known for its lightweight nature and distinct sonic properties. Its most famous use is in the soundboards of classical and flamenco guitars, where it is prized for producing a warm, immediate tone with a quick attack and a pronounced bass response. The wood is relatively soft and easy to work with, which makes it a favorite for luthiers but also means it is more susceptible to dents and environmental changes.

What is a Cedartone Pedal?

The term cedartone originates almost exclusively from the boutique pedal community, specifically describing a clone or variant of the celebrated Dallas Arbiter Fuzz Face. These pedals are meticulously engineered to replicate the exact circuit of the original 1960s units that Jimi Hendrix made famous. The "cedar" in cedartone refers not to the wood of the enclosure, but to the specific type of transistor used inside the circuit. True cedartone pedals utilize OC71 transistors, which are renowned for delivering the smooth, creamy, and slightly compressed distortion that defines the classic Fuzz Face sound, as opposed to the more harsh and gain-heavy silicon transistors found in many modern clones.

AD
10 Paint Colors For Cedar Siding
10 Paint Colors For Cedar Siding
the south house cedar is featured in this book
the south house cedar is featured in this book
Best Outdoor Finish for Cedar: Top Choices Explained
Best Outdoor Finish for Cedar: Top Choices Explained

Transistor Technology: The Core Difference

The heart of the distinction between a cedar-scented pedal and a cedartone lies in the semiconductor technology. While both pedals aim to create a fuzz effect, the choice of transistor dictates the resulting tone curve and dynamic response. Silicon transistors, common in high-gain modern pedals, switch on and off very quickly, creating a more aggressive and tighter fuzz. In contrast, the OC71 germanium transistors or modern equivalents designed to mimic them in a cedartone pedal compress the signal gently, producing the sought-after "fuzzy" and "dirtier" sound that blends beautifully with a clean amp channel.

Comparing Application and Use Case

When deciding between a device labeled cedartone and one described as cedar, it is best to consider the application. If you are looking for a guitar effect pedal, the term cedartone is the accurate descriptor for a high-quality Fuzz Face emulation. Conversely, if you are selecting materials for a piece of furniture, a guitar, or a scented item, you are dealing with cedar wood. The woodworking world values cedar for its natural resistance to insects and moisture, making it ideal for chests, closets, and lining drawers. In the music world, however, cedar tops are integral to the acoustic guitar's voice, providing a playable instrument that sounds sublime without being overly bright.

Cedar vs. Pine: Pros and Cons for Outdoor Furniture, Decks, and More
Cedar vs. Pine: Pros and Cons for Outdoor Furniture, Decks, and More
Cedar Siding Colors to Pair with Black Exterior
Cedar Siding Colors to Pair with Black Exterior
CertainTeed Cedar Impressions Vinyl Siding
CertainTeed Cedar Impressions Vinyl Siding

Debunking the Enclosure Myth

A frequent point of confusion arises from the cosmetic choices of pedal manufacturers. Many companies build Fuzz Face-style pedals using enclosures finished to look like wood, or they simply use real wood that is not specifically cedar. A pedal could have a pine or even birch enclosure painted to resemble cedar grain. Therefore, seeing a "cedar" enclosure does not guarantee the pedal sounds like a cedartone. Conversely, a cedartone pedal housed in a standard metal "paint can" enclosure will deliver the iconic tone regardless of the visual presentation. The sound is determined by the circuit, not the cosmetic veneer of the case.

Market Value and Sourcing

Aspect Cedar (Wood) Cedartone (Pedal)
Primary Source Lumber yards, specialized tonewood suppliers Effect pedal manufacturers (MXR, EarthQuaker, etc.)
Market Driver Sustainability, acoustic properties, aesthetics Semiconductor type (OC71, Germanium, Silicon)
Price Range Varies widely based on grade and origin $100 to $300+ for true OC71 based units
Sourcing Note Concerns regarding deforestation require responsible sourcing Vintage pedals are highly sought after and expensive

The economics of the two diverge significantly. High-quality cedar lumber, especially reclaimed or sustainably sourced wood, can command a premium price in the global market. The value of a cedartone pedal, however, is dictated by the rarity of the components and the demand for the specific tone. Original vintage MXR pedals are collector's items, but modern boutique versions using NOS (New Old Stock) OC71 transistors can fetch prices comparable to fine lumber, reflecting the niche desire for that specific harmonic saturation.

AD

Making the Right Choice for You

Navigating the terminology requires a shift in perspective based on context. If a friend mentions they just scored a piece of cedar, ask if it is for a smoking jacket or a guitar top. If they are talking about their new drive pedal, inquire if it is a true cedartone using germanium transistors. By recognizing that "cedar" is a botanical and material classification while "cedartone" is an audio engineering term, you cut through the noise. This clarity ensures that whether you are shaping sound with a pedal or shaping wood with a saw, you are working with the exact material or effect you intended, leading to more authentic and satisfying results in your craft or music.

Best Paint Colors That Go With Cedar Siding
Best Paint Colors That Go With Cedar Siding
What Colour Is Cedar: Stunning, Essential Guide
What Colour Is Cedar: Stunning, Essential Guide
25+ Vinyl Siding Exterior Ideas For An Easy, Modern Finish
25+ Vinyl Siding Exterior Ideas For An Easy, Modern Finish
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
Say Goodbye to High Maintenance with Composite Cedar Shake Siding - Home Improvement DIY
How to Paint Cedar Siding on a House (Prep, Prime & Finish in 7 Steps)
How to Paint Cedar Siding on a House (Prep, Prime & Finish in 7 Steps)
25 Cedar Front Door Colors Ideas: Natural Wood Tone Stains - Our Secondhand House
25 Cedar Front Door Colors Ideas: Natural Wood Tone Stains - Our Secondhand House
See How Much Our Cedar Shake Siding Color Has Changed After 3 Years | Nadine Stay
See How Much Our Cedar Shake Siding Color Has Changed After 3 Years | Nadine Stay
Cedar Care 101: Treating Wood for Outdoor Use
Cedar Care 101: Treating Wood for Outdoor Use
18+ Inspiring Cedar Sided House Ideas
18+ Inspiring Cedar Sided House Ideas
the color chart for cedar fence stain colors
the color chart for cedar fence stain colors
Different types of Cedar wood
Different types of Cedar wood
How to Finish Cedar for Outdoor Use: Easy Guide
How to Finish Cedar for Outdoor Use: Easy Guide
10 Paint Colors That Go with Cedar Trim
10 Paint Colors That Go with Cedar Trim
Cedar vs Douglas Fir: Pros and Cons for Home Construction
Cedar vs Douglas Fir: Pros and Cons for Home Construction
an exterior view of a home with the words exterior wood details above it in white letters
an exterior view of a home with the words exterior wood details above it in white letters
6 Ft Tall Cedar Wood Fences | Metal Posts
6 Ft Tall Cedar Wood Fences | Metal Posts
Why Cedar Siding Edges Are The Secret To A High-End Exterior On Any Budget
Why Cedar Siding Edges Are The Secret To A High-End Exterior On Any Budget
Knotty vs. Select Cedar
Knotty vs. Select Cedar
Cypress vs Cedar (Which is the Best? | Pros & Cons)
Cypress vs Cedar (Which is the Best? | Pros & Cons)
the different types of wood shingles are shown in this image, including light and medium
the different types of wood shingles are shown in this image, including light and medium
AD