2017 Outlander vs Highlander: Which Compact SUV Wins?
When comparing the 2017 Outlander versus Highlander, two distinct narratives emerge regarding mid-size crossover SUVs. While both vehicles share a similar target demographic of practical buyers, their core philosophies diverge significantly. The 2017 Mitsubishi Outlander presents itself as a versatile, tech-forward compact crossover focused on efficiency and adaptable capability. Conversely, the 2017 Toyota Highlander positions itself as a more substantial, traditional three-row midsize SUV prioritizing passenger volume and Toyota's renowned reliability. This comparison dissects the key differences in design, performance, space, and value for the discerning shopper.
The Design and First Impressions Showdown
Visual identity plays a crucial role in the 2017 Outlander vs Highlander debate, with each brand projecting a different aesthetic language. The 2017 Outlander embraced a sharper, more aggressive design language featuring a bold front grille, sculpted wheel arches, and LED lighting elements that gave it a distinctly modern and sporty presence. Mitsubishi aimed to move away from the boxy image of its predecessor, creating a vehicle that looked more dynamic and integrated. In contrast, the 2017 Highlander adopted a more conservative and familiar Toyota design, characterized by a clean, somewhat bland front end with a prominent bowtie grill and gently flowing lines. Its design prioritized inoffensiveness and familiarity over statement-making, appearing larger and more imposing due to its true three-row layout. Ultimately, the choice often came down to whether a buyer preferred the Outlander’s contemporary edge or the Highlander’s traditional family-van demeanor.
Dimensional Differences and Interior Real Estate
Size is a defining factor in the 2017 Outlander versus Highlander conversation, particularly concerning interior space and cargo utility. The Highlander, as a certified midsize SUV, boasts significantly more passenger and cargo volume. Its standard third row, while not spacious for adults on long trips, provided a crucial advantage for families needing to squeeze in seven passengers occasionally. The Outlander, classified as a compact crossover, offered a more manageable profile for urban driving and parking but fell short in pure capacity. Its rear seat was comfortable for children or shorter adults, and its cargo area behind the rear seats was more limited. However, the Outlander’s rear seats folded flat much more easily, creating a genuinely versatile cargo bed that could handle awkwardly shaped items better than the Highlander’s more constrained space.
Performance, Efficiency, and Driving Dynamics
The driving experience in the 2017 models highlighted the different priorities of the Outlander and Highlander. The 2017 Outlander offered a choice between a standard front-wheel-drive system and available Mitsubishi's S-AWC (Super All-Wheel Control), which provided superior traction and handling in various weather conditions. Its available 2.4-liter inline-four engine was adequate for daily driving, prioritizing smoothness and fuel economy over raw power. The continuously variable transmission (CVT) contributed to efficient operation. The 2017 Highlander, depending on trim, typically came with a more powerful 3.5-liter V6 engine, delivering confident highway merging and passing power. Its six-speed automatic transmission shifted smoothly but was less efficient than the Outlander’s CVT. The Highlander’s larger physical footprint also made it feel less agile in tight city environments, whereas the Outlander’s tighter turning radius was a distinct advantage for everyday errands.
Technology, Comfort, and Available Features
Technology and feature sets were areas where the 2017 Outlander aimed to punch well above its weight class against the Highlander. Mitsubishi placed a strong emphasis on infotainment, offering the newer Entegra system with a large, high-resolution touchscreen, navigation, and smartphone integration (Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, often requiring higher trims). The Outlander’s interior materials were generally more modern and better perceived in its higher trims. Conversely, the 2017 Highlander’s interior, while clean and well-built with available premium materials, leaned towards a more utilitarian and slightly dated design. Its infotainment system, while functional, was not as polished or integrated as the Outlander’s. Furthermore, the Outlander frequently included standard safety features like forward collision mitigation and lane departure warning, which were often reserved for higher trims on the Highlander, making the Outlander a compelling value in the base and mid-level trims.
Reliability, Ownership Costs, and the Value Proposition
Long-term ownership considerations heavily influence the 2017 Outlander vs Highlander evaluation, where Toyota’s reputation for durability holds significant weight. The Highlander has consistently been praised for its legendary reliability and lower cost of ownership over time. Toyota’s reputation for longevity translates into higher resale values and fewer unexpected repair bills. Mitsubishi, while offering competitive warranties, historically had a less robust reliability record compared to Toyota, which could impact long-term peace of mind. Fuel economy also favored the Outlander, particularly its CVT-equipped variants, which often achieved better MPG figures than the thirstier V6 Highlander. Buyers needed to weigh the initial purchase price against the projected ownership costs over several years, with the Highlander often presenting a safer financial bet despite the Outlander’s attractive feature set.
The Final Verdict for the Modern Buyer
Choosing between the 2017 Outlander and Highlander ultimately depends on individual priorities and usage patterns. The 2017 Outlander is the ideal choice for the driver-centric buyer who values modern technology, agile handling, and superior fuel efficiency in a more compact package. It suits urban dwellers and small families who appreciate its versatile cargo space and all-weather capability without committing to a large vehicle. The 2017 Highlander, however, remains the superior choice for larger families or those who prioritize maximum passenger and cargo space, absolute reliability, and strong resale value. Its more powerful engine and traditional SUV presence cater to those who need that third row and prefer a more commanding road position. There is no single winner, only the right tool for the specific needs of the buyer.